TL;DR
Condition is a trust signal. Pick the honest tag, name flaws plainly, and show them in photos. Honest condition means fewer no-shows and better reviews.
Condition is where trust is won or lost. Marketplace gives you condition tags like New, Used Like New, Used Good, and Used Fair, and the buyer reads them alongside your description and photos. Overstate the condition and you get cancellations at pickup and unhappy buyers.
Pick the right tag
- New: unused, in original packaging, never opened.
- Used Like New: barely used, no visible flaws, looks new.
- Used Good: normal wear, fully working, minor cosmetic marks.
- Used Fair: heavier wear or a notable flaw, still functional.
- When in doubt, choose the lower tag and let the item pleasantly surprise.
The tag sets the expectation, and the description fills in the detail. Say exactly what the wear is: "small scratch on the left side, not visible from the front" beats a vague "good condition." Specific honesty tells the buyer you are straight with them.
Show flaws, do not hide them
Back up your condition tag with photos. A close-up of a scratch looks worse in the photo than in person and it removes any surprise at pickup. Hiding a flaw to make a sale just turns into a cancellation and a wasted meetup for both of you.
Honest condition is also good pricing discipline. If an item is Used Fair, price it against Used Fair comps, not Like New ones. Matching condition to price keeps your listings believable and your reviews strong.
Common questions
Which condition tag should I use if I am unsure?
Choose the lower of the two you are debating. A buyer who expected less and gets more is delighted, while one who expected more and gets less cancels or leaves a bad review. Underpromising protects your reputation.
How detailed should I be about flaws?
Very. Name exactly what the wear is and where, like a small scratch on the left side not visible from the front. Specific honesty beats a vague good condition and builds trust with the buyer.
Should I photograph the flaws?
Yes. A close-up of a scratch or stain looks worse in the photo than in person and removes any surprise at pickup. Showing flaws upfront cuts no-shows and cancellations.
Does condition affect how I price an item?
It should. Price against comps in the same condition. If an item is Used Fair, use Used Fair comps, not Like New ones. Matching condition to price keeps your listings believable.
What happens if I overstate the condition?
You get cancellations at pickup, wasted meetups, and unhappy buyers who may leave poor feedback. Overstating condition to make a sale almost always backfires once the buyer sees the item in person.
Is Used Like New too generous for most items?
It should mean barely used with no visible flaws. If there is any noticeable wear, drop to Used Good. Reserve Like New for items that genuinely look new so the tag keeps its meaning.
Keep going
Get condition wording checked for $9/month
Get the other 14 in the pricing stack, plus the full FB Marketplace Resellers Club community - $9/mo, cancel anytime.
Join the Club